Private Schools in Tavernier, Florida

Island Christian School is a highly-regarded private Christian school serving the Upper Keys community since 1986. The school offers comprehensive education from preschool through 12th grade with a strong college preparatory curriculum. Known for its small class sizes and personalized attention, the school features robust STEM programs, competitive athletics, and extensive fine arts offerings. The campus includes modern classrooms, science labs, athletic facilities, and dedicated arts spaces. Parents consistently praise the school's nurturing environment, academic rigor, and strong community values.

Located just minutes from Tavernier in Islamorada, Treasure Village Montessori has been serving Upper Keys families since 1977. As an American Montessori Society accredited school, it offers authentic Montessori education for students from toddler through middle school. The school features a unique coastal campus with outdoor classrooms, gardens, and direct access to natural learning environments. Their program emphasizes hands-on learning, environmental stewardship, Spanish language acquisition, and individualized academic pacing. The school is renowned for developing independent, critical thinkers with strong community engagement.

While part of the public school system, Coral Shores High School's Cambridge AICE Program functions as a premier academic track that many families consider as a private-school-level option. The rigorous Cambridge curriculum offers internationally recognized diplomas and college credit opportunities. The program features specialized courses in marine science (leveraging the school's unique Florida Keys location), advanced mathematics, and comprehensive humanities. Students benefit from small class sizes within the program, dedicated faculty, and exceptional college acceptance rates. The campus includes state-of-the-art science labs, performing arts center, and athletic facilities serving the entire Upper Keys community.