BestPrivateSchoolsNear.me
Excellence Verified

The Best Private Schools in Cicero, Indiana

Discover 3 exceptional private schools in Cicero. Find the perfect educational environment for your child with our comprehensive reviews and ratings.

3
Private Schools
4.7
Average Rating
0
Total Students
2
School Types

School Overview

0
Religious Schools
3
Secular Schools
2
Different Types

Top-Rated Private Schools

Sycamore School

Independent

4.8

Sycamore School is Indiana's only independent school specifically designed for academically gifted students, serving families throughout Hamilton County including Cicero. The school offers a challenging curriculum tailored to gifted learners from preschool through 8th grade. With specialized programs in advanced mathematics, science research, and humanities, Sycamore provides an intellectually stimulating environment. The school features state-of-the-art science labs, technology integration, and extensive arts facilities. Parent satisfaction is exceptionally high due to the school's focus on meeting the unique needs of gifted children and its strong community atmosphere.

1750 W 64th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260, Cicero, Indiana IN 46260
Grades: K-12
Founded 1985

Programs:

Gifted educationAdvanced STEMHumanities+1 more

Noblesville Schools Montessori

Private Montessori

4.7

Located just minutes from Cicero in neighboring Noblesville, this highly-rated Montessori school serves families throughout Hamilton County. The school offers authentic Montessori education for children ages 3 through 12, with mixed-age classrooms that promote peer learning and leadership. The program emphasizes individualized learning plans, hands-on materials, and development of executive functioning skills. The school features beautifully prepared Montessori environments, outdoor learning spaces, and a strong focus on character development. With AMI-trained teachers and a commitment to Montessori principles, the school has built an excellent reputation for academic preparation and student development.

1775 Field Dr, Noblesville, IN 46060, Cicero, Indiana IN 46060
Grades: K-12
Founded 1998

Programs:

Montessori educationEarly childhood through elementaryPractical life skills+1 more

The Orchard School

Independent

4.6

The Orchard School is a highly-regarded independent school serving the greater Indianapolis area, including Cicero families. With over a century of educational excellence, Orchard offers a progressive, child-centered education from preschool through 8th grade. The school's 43-acre campus features extensive outdoor learning spaces, modern classrooms, and specialized facilities for arts and sciences. Their Reggio Emilia-inspired approach emphasizes hands-on learning, critical thinking, and creative expression. Orchard maintains small class sizes with a 8:1 student-teacher ratio and offers comprehensive extracurricular programs including athletics, robotics, and performing arts.

615 W 64th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260, Cicero, Indiana IN 46260
Grades: K-12
Founded 1922

Programs:

Reggio Emilia-inspired curriculumSTEM programsArts integration+1 more

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about private schools in Cicero, Indiana

What are the primary private school options available for families residing in Cicero, Indiana, and how accessible are they?

While Cicero itself is a small town, families have access to several highly-regarded private schools in the surrounding Hamilton County area. The schools you mentioned—The Orchard School and Sycamore School—are located in Indianapolis, approximately a 30-minute drive south. Noblesville Schools Montessori is in neighboring Noblesville, about a 15-minute drive. These are the most prominent options, but other parochial and independent schools in nearby Fishers, Carmel, and Indianapolis are also within commuting distance. For Cicero residents, accessibility is primarily by car, as there are no major private school campuses within the town limits itself.

How does tuition for top-tier private schools near Cicero, IN, compare to the state average, and what financial aid options are available?

Tuition for schools like The Orchard School and Sycamore School is significantly above the Indiana private school average, often ranging from $20,000 to $25,000+ annually for lower/middle school. Indiana offers the School Choice Scholarship (voucher) program, which can substantially reduce costs for eligible families. Eligibility is primarily based on income, with thresholds tied to the Free and Reduced Lunch program. Many private schools also offer their own need-based financial aid. It's crucial for Cicero parents to apply for both the state voucher and institutional aid early in the admissions process, as funds are limited.

What unique academic programs or specializations do private schools in the Cicero area offer that differentiate them from local public schools?

The private schools accessible to Cicero families offer distinct educational models not typically found in the public school system. Sycamore School is Indiana's only accredited independent school specifically for gifted students, offering a profoundly accelerated curriculum. The Orchard School emphasizes experiential, project-based learning with a 43-acre campus featuring wetlands and forests for outdoor education. Noblesville Schools Montessori follows the authentic Montessori method for early childhood and elementary education. In contrast, Cicero's public schools are part of the Hamilton Heights School Corporation, which, while well-regarded, follows a more traditional curriculum and structure.

What is the typical enrollment timeline and process for competitive private schools near Cicero, Indiana?

The timeline is critical and requires planning a year in advance. For schools like The Orchard and Sycamore, the process for the following fall typically begins in August/September with open houses. Application deadlines are often in January or February, with assessments, student visits, and interviews occurring in the winter. Admission decisions are usually released in March. Given the competitive nature and limited seats, Cicero parents are advised to start researching and touring schools in the fall, especially as sibling and legacy applicants often receive priority. Waiting lists are common, so applying by the deadline is essential.

For a family living in Cicero, what are the practical considerations regarding the commute and community when choosing a private school outside the town?

Choosing a private school means committing to a daily commute, which can be 15-45 minutes each way to Noblesville, Carmel, Fishers, or Indianapolis. Parents should consider carpool opportunities with other local families, as well as before/after-school care options for longer days. Community integration can also differ; your child's friends and extracurricular activities will likely be centered around the school's location, not Cicero. However, many families find the specialized education worth the travel. It's advisable to connect with current families from the Cicero area during your school research to understand their real-world logistics and experiences.

Private Education Insights

Discover the Best Private Pre-K Programs in Cicero, Indiana: A Parent's Guide

For families in Cicero, the decision about where to begin your child’s educational journey is a significant one. The foundational years of pre-kindergarten are about so much more than learning letters and numbers; they are about nurturing curiosity, building social confidence, and fostering a genuine love for learning in a safe and supportive environment. Exploring private pre k options in our community offers a distinct pathway, often characterized by smaller class sizes, specialized educational philosophies, and a strong sense of community—factors that many Cicero parents find invaluable. The local landscape here in Hamilton County provides several excellent, yet distinctly different, approaches to early childhood education, allowing you to find a program that aligns perfectly with your family’s values and your child’s unique needs.

One of the primary considerations for Cicero families is the blend of a nurturing atmosphere with academic preparedness. Many private pre k programs in our area, including those at esteemed institutions like The Orchard School and Sycamore School, though a short commute away, are designed with this balance in mind. These schools often employ experienced early childhood educators who understand how to structure play-based learning that seamlessly introduces foundational literacy and numeracy concepts. The low student-to-teacher ratio typical of private settings means your child receives more individualized attention, allowing educators to tailor activities to spark each child’s interests, whether they are fascinated by bugs in a nature exploration or the mechanics of building a block tower. This personalized approach can be especially beneficial in these formative years.

When researching private pre k in Cicero, you’ll encounter specific educational philosophies that shape the daily experience. For instance, the Noblesville Schools Montessori program, accessible to Cicero residents, offers a quintessential Montessori environment for young learners. Here, the focus is on self-directed activity within a carefully prepared classroom, encouraging independence, concentration, and a sense of order. This contrasts with more traditional or play-based models, highlighting the importance of visiting schools to feel the environment firsthand. Consider your daily logistics as well. Cicero’s location provides a peaceful, small-town setting, but factoring in commute times to programs in nearby Noblesville or Indianapolis is a practical step. Many families find the drive worthwhile for a program that feels like the perfect fit, often carpooling with other local families.

Ultimately, choosing a private pre k is an investment in your child’s first formal school experience. It’s about finding a place where they feel known, safe, and excited to explore. We encourage Cicero parents to schedule tours, ask detailed questions about curriculum and social-emotional learning, and observe how teachers interact with students. Pay attention to the community feel—does it seem like a place where your family would connect? The right private pre k program will not only prepare your child academically but will also instill the confidence and joy that turns them into a lifelong learner, setting a positive trajectory for all their educational years to come.

Nearby Cities

Explore private schools in nearby cities