The Best Private Schools in Middlebury, Indiana
Discover 3 exceptional private schools in Middlebury. Find the perfect educational environment for your child with our comprehensive reviews and ratings.
School Overview
Top-Rated Private Schools
Trinity School at Greenlawn
Independent Catholic School
Trinity School at Greenlawn is a premier classical education institution serving students from Middlebury and surrounding communities. The school offers a rigorous liberal arts education grounded in the Western tradition with emphasis on the Great Books, Socratic dialogue, and character formation. Academic programs include four years of Latin, comprehensive mathematics and science curriculum, philosophy, theology, and extensive writing instruction. The campus features historic buildings with modern academic facilities, science laboratories, music rooms, and athletic spaces. Trinity graduates consistently achieve exceptional college placement results with many attending top-tier universities. The school maintains small class sizes and emphasizes the development of virtuous leaders through integrated academic and spiritual formation.
Programs:
Bethany Christian Schools
Mennonite Education Agency
Bethany Christian Schools is a highly-regarded private institution serving the Middlebury area with a comprehensive college-preparatory education rooted in Anabaptist Christian values. The school offers rigorous academic programs including Advanced Placement courses, robust STEM education, and extensive fine arts opportunities. Facilities include modern classrooms, science laboratories, performing arts spaces, and athletic complexes. The school maintains small class sizes with a student-teacher ratio of 12:1 and has a strong track record of college acceptance. Extracurricular programs encompass championship athletics, music ensembles, theater productions, and service learning opportunities.
Programs:
The Montessori Academy of Northern Indiana
American Montessori Society
The Montessori Academy of Northern Indiana provides exceptional Montessori education serving families throughout the region including Middlebury. The school offers authentic Montessori programming from toddler through eighth grade with certified Montessori teachers and comprehensive curriculum. Facilities include purpose-built Montessori classrooms, outdoor learning environments, science labs, and art studios. The academy emphasizes individualized learning, hands-on exploration, and development of independent thinking skills. Students benefit from foreign language instruction, music education, physical education, and community outreach programs. The school maintains AMS accreditation and serves as a demonstration school for Montessori teacher education.
Programs:
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about private schools in Middlebury, Indiana
What are the primary private school options available for families in Middlebury, Indiana, and what are their core educational philosophies?
Middlebury, Indiana, is served by a few distinct private school options, each with a unique approach. **Bethany Christian Schools** offers a comprehensive Pre-K through 12th grade education rooted in Anabaptist-Mennonite Christian values. **The Montessori Academy of Northern Indiana** provides child-centered, hands-on Montessori education for children from toddler through middle school ages. **Trinity School at Greenlawn**, located in nearby South Bend, is a popular choice for Middlebury families seeking a classical, Great Books-based liberal arts education with a strong Christian foundation. These schools provide alternatives to the Middlebury Community Schools public system, catering to specific religious, pedagogical, and academic preferences.
How does tuition at private schools in the Middlebury, IN, area compare, and are there Indiana-specific financial aid programs available?
Tuition varies significantly based on the school and grade level. For the 2024-2025 academic year, Bethany Christian Schools' tuition ranges from approximately $6,000 for elementary to over $10,000 for high school. The Montessori Academy typically has tuition in a similar range, varying by program level. Trinity School at Greenlawn's tuition is higher, often exceeding $15,000. Crucially, Indiana residents benefit from the state's **School Choice Scholarship (Voucher) Program**. Families meeting certain income thresholds can use state funds to help cover tuition at participating private schools, which includes Bethany Christian. Additionally, all schools offer their own need-based financial aid and payment plans.
What unique academic or extracurricular programs do private schools near Middlebury, Indiana, offer that differentiate them?
Schools in the area offer specialized programs that leverage local resources and distinct missions. **Bethany Christian Schools** has a renowned music program and strong agricultural/FFA ties reflective of the Elkhart County community, along with service-learning trips. **The Montessori Academy** emphasizes individualized learning plans, outdoor education, and practical life skills in a multi-age classroom setting. **Trinity School at Greenlawn** is distinguished by its Socratic seminars, rigorous Latin program, and senior thesis defense—a hallmark of its classical curriculum. For families in Middlebury, these programs offer alternatives to the standard public school curriculum, with a focus on specific pedagogical outcomes or faith integration.
What is the typical enrollment timeline and process for private schools serving Middlebury, Indiana, families?
The timeline is generally consistent across schools, starting early in the calendar year. Most schools begin accepting applications for the following fall between January and March, with priority deadlines often in February or March. The process usually involves an application form, submission of records, family interviews (and student assessments/interviews for some grades), and a campus tour. **Bethany Christian**, being a local community school, may have specific timelines for congregational member registration. **Trinity School**, due to its competitive nature and draw from a wider region, has an earlier and more structured admissions process. It's highly advised to contact schools by December or January to ensure you meet all deadlines and understand any waitlist procedures.
For a family living in Middlebury, what are the practical considerations regarding transportation and community when choosing a local private school versus one in South Bend?
This is a key logistical decision. **Bethany Christian Schools** and **The Montessori Academy** are located within a short drive in the Middlebury/Goshen area, minimizing commute time and fostering a local peer community. Choosing **Trinity School at Greenlawn** in South Bend involves a 25-30 minute commute each way. While Trinity offers a distinctive education, this means coordinating carpools, adjusting for weather-related travel, and your child's social circle being more geographically dispersed. Many Middlebury families choose Bethany for its deep local roots and convenience, while others are willing to commute for Trinity's specific classical model. Evaluating the daily time commitment and community connection is as important as comparing academic programs.
Nearby Cities
Explore private schools in nearby cities