The Best Private Schools in Stonington, Maine
Discover 3 exceptional private schools in Stonington. Find the perfect educational environment for your child with our comprehensive reviews and ratings.
School Overview
Top-Rated Private Schools
The Island Community School
Independent
The Island Community School serves the Deer Isle-Stonington peninsula with a progressive, project-based educational approach. Located just minutes from Stonington, this highly-rated independent school emphasizes hands-on learning, environmental stewardship, and community engagement. The school offers small class sizes with a 6:1 student-teacher ratio, integrated marine science programs that leverage the coastal location, and comprehensive outdoor education. Their curriculum focuses on developing critical thinking skills through real-world projects, with strong emphasis on sustainability and local ecology. The school serves students from preschool through 8th grade and maintains deep connections with the Stonington fishing and lobstering community.
Programs:
The Bay School
Independent
Located approximately 30 minutes from Stonington in Blue Hill, The Bay School is a highly-regarded Montessori school serving students from toddler through 8th grade. The school is known for its exceptional academic program that combines Montessori principles with environmental education and arts integration. Facilities include extensive outdoor learning spaces, science laboratories, and art studios. The curriculum emphasizes individualized learning plans, community responsibility, and environmental stewardship. Many Stonington families choose The Bay School for its strong academic foundation, inclusive community, and commitment to developing independent, creative thinkers. The school offers transportation options for families from the Stonington area.
Programs:
George Stevens Academy
Independent
George Stevens Academy is an independent day and boarding school serving the Blue Hill Peninsula and surrounding communities, including Stonington. With over two centuries of educational excellence, GSA offers a comprehensive college preparatory program for grades 9-12. The academy features state-of-the-art science facilities, strong marine science programs that benefit from the coastal location, and outstanding visual and performing arts departments. The school maintains small class sizes and offers extensive extracurricular opportunities including competitive athletics, sailing, and community service programs. Many Stonington students attend GSA for its rigorous academics, personalized attention, and strong track record of college placements. The school provides transportation services for students from the Stonington area.
Programs:
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about private schools in Stonington, Maine
What are the primary private school options available for families in Stonington, Maine, and what age groups do they serve?
Stonington, located on Deer Isle, offers a few distinctive private school options, each with a different focus. The Island Community School is a Pre-K through 8th grade school emphasizing place-based, experiential learning rooted in the local coastal environment. The Bay School, also for grades Pre-K through 8, is a Montessori school that fosters independent learning. For high school, many Stonington families look to George Stevens Academy in nearby Blue Hill, which serves grades 9-12 and is known for its strong college preparatory and marine studies programs. The availability is limited, especially for high school, so exploring schools in neighboring Penobscot Bay communities is common.
How does tuition at private schools in the Stonington, ME area compare, and are there financial aid options for Maine residents?
Tuition varies significantly. For the 2024-25 academic year, The Island Community School and The Bay School have tuitions in the range of $10,000-$15,000 for elementary grades. George Stevens Academy's tuition is approximately $18,000 for day students. Financial aid is a priority at these schools, funded through endowments and annual fundraising. As a Maine resident, you should also investigate the Maine Town Tuitioning Program, which may provide tuition assistance for students from towns without public schools at their grade level to attend approved private schools, a relevant option for some island communities.
What unique academic or extracurricular programs do Stonington-area private schools offer that leverage the local coastal environment?
Schools here deeply integrate the unique setting into their curricula. The Island Community School has a renowned maritime studies program where students learn boat building, sailing, and marine ecology. The Bay School's Montessori approach includes extensive outdoor education in its coastal forest campus. George Stevens Academy offers a signature Marine Studies program, including hands-on oceanography, aquaculture, and even a commercial fishing license course. These programs provide unparalleled experiential learning tied directly to the local economy and ecosystem, something rarely found in inland schools.
What is the typical enrollment timeline and process for private schools like The Island Community School or The Bay School in Stonington?
Given their small size (often 50-100 students total), these schools have rolling admissions but encourage early application. The process typically begins in the winter (January-February) for the following fall. It involves a completed application, parent and student visits/interviews, teacher recommendations, and school records. Decision notifications are often made by March or April. It's crucial to contact the schools directly as soon as you're interested, as spaces, particularly in specific grade levels, are very limited. Sibling and legacy applicants often receive priority.
For families considering both options, how do the private schools in Stonington compare to the local public school, Deer Isle-Stonington Elementary School?
The public Deer Isle-Stonington Elementary School serves Pre-K through 8 and is part of the Union 76/CSD 13 system. The key differences are scale, approach, and high school pathway. The public school is larger and offers a standard Maine curriculum. The private options offer smaller class sizes (often 10-15 students), specific pedagogical approaches (Montessori or place-based), and more flexible, experiential learning. For high school, public students typically attend Deer Isle-Stonington High School, while private elementary graduates often seek placement at George Stevens Academy or other private high schools. The choice often hinges on a family's preference for educational philosophy and community size.