Skip to content
BestPrivateSchoolsNear.me

The Best Private Schools in Highland Park, New Jersey

Discover 3 private schools in Highland Park, ranked by public ratings and review volume. How we rank

Top-Rated Private Schools in Highland Park

  1. Number 1: St Matthews School

    Catholic SchoolFounded 1954

    St Matthews School is a Catholic school in Edison, NJ, serving students from Pre-Kindergarten through eighth grade. Its curriculum emphasizes STREAM (Science, Technology, Religion, Engineering, Art, and Math), and extracurricular offerings include robotics, band, and sports. Starting in the 2026-27 school year, the school will transition to offering Pre-Kindergarten only, ending its elementary and middle school programs.

    • Early Childhood Education
    • Elementary Education
    • Middle School
    • STEM

    100 Seymour Ave, Edison, NJ 08817

    (732) 985-6633

  2. Number 2: An-Noor Academy

    Islamic School

    An-Noor Academy is a private Islamic school in Piscataway, New Jersey, serving students from Pre-Kindergarten through 12th grade. Its educational approach combines academics with Islamic values, and its curriculum includes Advanced Placement courses and a Tahfeez program for Quran memorization.

    • K-12 Education
    • Early Childhood Education
    • Advanced Placement
    • Religious Education

    1000 Hoes Ln W, Piscataway, NJ 08854

    (732) 667-5300

  3. Number 3: Metuchen Christian Academy

    Christian School

    Metuchen Christian Academy is a private Christian school serving students in grades K-8 in Metuchen, New Jersey, and the surrounding communities. Affiliated with the Assemblies of God, the school offers a faith-based curriculum that integrates Christian values with standard academic subjects. It also provides sports programs and emphasizes character development alongside academic growth.

    • Elementary Education
    • Middle School
    • Christian Education
    • Athletics

    130 Whitman Ave, Metuchen, NJ 08840

    (732) 549-7854

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about private schools in Highland Park, New Jersey

What are the primary private school options serving families in Highland Park, NJ, and are they located within the borough?

While Highland Park itself is a small borough, it is exceptionally well-positioned near several top-tier private schools. The private schools listed for Highland Park are St Matthews School in Edison (about 2 miles away), An-Noor Academy in Piscataway (about 3 miles away), and Metuchen Christian Academy in Metuchen (about 4 miles away). Many Highland Park families choose these schools for their rigorous academics, extensive extracurriculars, and college preparatory focus. The local public school district also has a strong reputation, making the decision one of specific educational philosophy and program fit.

How does tuition for top private schools near Highland Park, NJ, compare, and what financial aid options are typically available?

Tuition for the leading schools in the area is significant and aligns with the high cost of living in Central New Jersey. Families should contact the schools directly for current tuition figures and financial aid details. It is crucial to apply for financial aid concurrently with admission, as deadlines are strict. Additionally, New Jersey's "Opportunity Scholarship Act" tax credit program is not currently active, so most aid comes directly from the schools' endowments.

What unique academic or extracurricular programs draw Highland Park families to local private schools?

The private schools near Highland Park distinguish themselves with specialized programs that complement the strong STEM focus found in many New Jersey public schools. For example, St Matthews School in Edison, NJ, about 2 miles from Highland Park, emphasizes STREAM (Science, Technology, Religion, Engineering, Art, and Math), and its extracurricular offerings include robotics, band, and sports. An-Noor Academy in Piscataway, NJ, about 3 miles from Highland Park, combines academics with Islamic values, and its curriculum includes Advanced Placement courses and a Tahfeez program for Quran memorization. Metuchen Christian Academy in Metuchen, NJ, about 4 miles from Highland Park, offers a faith-based curriculum that integrates Christian values with standard academic subjects, and it also provides sports programs and emphasizes character development alongside academic growth. For Highland Park parents, these programs offer a level of specialization and resource intensity that, while available in some public magnet programs, is consistently integrated into the daily curriculum at these private institutions.

What is the typical enrollment timeline and process for competitive private schools in the Highland Park, NJ, area?

The admission process for schools like Wardlaw+Hartridge, Rutgers Prep, and Princeton Day is highly structured and begins well in advance. The timeline typically starts in the fall (September-October) a full year before desired entry. Key steps include: attending open houses (often in the fall), submitting applications by January deadlines, completing student interviews and visits, and taking standardized tests like the ISEE or SSAT. Notification dates are usually in March for the following September. Given the competitive nature, especially for entry into middle and high school grades, starting the process early is essential. Many families from Highland Park begin researching and touring schools 18-24 months in advance.

For families living in Highland Park, what are the key considerations when comparing the highly-rated public schools to nearby private options?

This is a central decision for Highland Park residents. The Highland Park Public Schools are consistently highly rated, offering a small, community-focused K-12 experience with notable strengths in diversity and inclusive programming. The primary considerations for opting for a private school often revolve around class size, specialized facilities, and specific educational trajectories. Private schools typically offer smaller average class sizes (e.g., 12-15 students vs. 20+), more extensive athletic and arts facilities, and a curriculum designed explicitly for a college-preparatory track. The trade-off, beyond cost, often includes a longer commute and a potentially less socio-economically diverse student body than the Highland Park public schools. The decision frequently comes down to seeking a particular pedagogical approach or program depth that aligns with a child's specific needs and interests.

Private Education Insights

Discover Top-Rated Secular Private Schools Near Highland Park, NJ

For families in Highland Park, New Jersey, beginning the search for “secular private schools near me” opens a door to a remarkable concentration of educational excellence right in our backyard. The quest is not merely about finding a school without religious affiliation, but about identifying a community that aligns with your family’s values, academic aspirations, and desire for a well-rounded education. Fortunately, our central location in the heart of the Garden State places some of the region's most prestigious independent schools within a manageable commute, each offering a distinct approach to secular education.

The local landscape is defined by schools that are not just institutions, but long-standing pillars of academic and personal development. St Matthews School is a Catholic school in Edison, NJ, about 2 miles from Highland Park, serving students from Pre-Kindergarten through eighth grade. Its curriculum emphasizes STREAM (Science, Technology, Religion, Engineering, Art, and Math), and extracurricular offerings include robotics, band, and sports. An-Noor Academy is a private Islamic school in Piscataway, NJ, about 3 miles from Highland Park, serving students from Pre-Kindergarten through 12th grade. Its educational approach combines academics with Islamic values, and its curriculum includes Advanced Placement courses and a Tahfeez program for Quran memorization. Metuchen Christian Academy is a private Christian school serving students in grades K-8 in Metuchen, NJ, about 4 miles from Highland Park. Affiliated with the Assemblies of God, the school offers a faith-based curriculum that integrates Christian values with standard academic subjects.

When researching “secular private schools near me” from Highland Park, practical considerations are uniquely shaped by our location. The commute is a real factor; Route 27 and the New Jersey Turnpike become familiar roads, but each school’s culture is worth the travel. Many local families find carpool networks, which are common in our tight-knit borough, to be invaluable. It’s also crucial to look beyond the impressive names and examine the philosophical fit. Secular in this context means the ethical framework is built on humanistic values, community service, and respect for diverse perspectives—a perfect match for Highland Park’s own vibrant, eclectic character. Consider what your child needs: Does a school with a sprawling campus like Wardlaw+Hartridge’s 36 acres appeal, or the collegiate atmosphere of Rutgers Prep? Are you drawn to Princeton Day’s emphasis on student-driven inquiry?

The process is deeply personal. We recommend starting your search by attending open houses, which these schools host regularly. This allows you to feel the community vibe, talk to current parents—many of whom will be from Highland Park and surrounding towns—and see the facilities firsthand. Speak to admissions officers about your specific hopes for your child’s education. Remember, “near me” is about more than geography; it’s about finding an academic home that feels connected to your family’s life in our wonderful borough. The investment in this search is an investment in a learning environment where your child can thrive intellectually and socially, free to explore their identity and passions within a framework of excellence and integrity. The ideal secular private school is out there, waiting to become an extension of your Highland Park home.

Keep exploring