The Best Private Schools in Atlanta, New York
Discover 3 exceptional private schools in Atlanta. Find the perfect educational environment for your child with our comprehensive reviews and ratings.
School Overview
Top-Rated Private Schools
Allendale Columbia School
Independent
Allendale Columbia School is a premier independent day school serving students from preschool through grade 12. Located in Rochester, approximately 45 minutes from Atlanta, NY, the school offers a rigorous academic program including both International Baccalaureate and Advanced Placement courses. The campus features state-of-the-art science labs, performing arts centers, and athletic facilities. With small class sizes and a student-teacher ratio of 7:1, the school provides personalized attention and has a 100% college acceptance rate. The school emphasizes global citizenship and offers extensive extracurricular programs including robotics, debate, and championship athletic teams.
Programs:
The Harley School
Independent
The Harley School is an independent, college-preparatory school serving students from toddler through 12th grade. Located in the Brighton area of Rochester, the school combines rigorous academics with a focus on character development and community engagement. The school features a 25-acre campus with modern classrooms, science and innovation labs, art studios, and athletic facilities. Harley's curriculum includes both International Baccalaureate and Advanced Placement options, with particular strengths in STEM education and environmental science. The school maintains small class sizes and offers extensive arts, athletics, and service-learning opportunities.
Programs:
McQuaid Jesuit
Jesuit Schools Network
McQuaid Jesuit is an all-boys Catholic school serving grades 6-12, located in Rochester and serving students from throughout the region including Atlanta, NY. As part of the Jesuit educational tradition, the school emphasizes academic excellence, faith formation, and service to others. The comprehensive college preparatory program includes 23 Advanced Placement courses and specialized programs in engineering, robotics, and computer science. The 35-acre campus features modern academic buildings, extensive athletic facilities, and technology-enhanced classrooms. McQuaid maintains a 100% college acceptance rate and offers robust extracurricular programs including championship athletic teams, performing arts, and community service initiatives.
Programs:
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about private schools in Atlanta, New York
What are the distinctive educational philosophies of the top private schools in Atlanta, New York, such as Allendale Columbia, The Harley School, and McQuaid Jesuit?
The leading private schools in Atlanta, NY, offer diverse educational approaches. Allendale Columbia School in nearby Rochester emphasizes experiential, student-centered learning with a strong global focus. The Harley School, also in Rochester, is known for its progressive, Reggio Emilia-inspired early childhood program and its commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion. McQuaid Jesuit in Brighton provides a rigorous, college-preparatory education rooted in the Jesuit tradition of forming "men for others," with a strong emphasis on service and character. This variety allows Atlanta, NY, families to choose a school whose philosophy closely aligns with their values and their child's learning style.
How does tuition for private schools in the Atlanta, NY, area compare to the state average, and what financial aid options are typically available?
Tuition for private day schools in the Atlanta, NY, area (primarily in the greater Rochester region) is generally below the average for downstate New York but is a significant family investment. For the 2023-24 academic year, tuition at schools like Harley and Allendale Columbia ranges from approximately $20,000 to $30,000 for grades K-12. McQuaid Jesuit's tuition is similarly structured. Importantly, these schools offer substantial need-based financial aid, with many families receiving grants that do not require repayment. Schools also often offer payment plans. It's crucial to apply for financial aid early, as deadlines often precede admission decisions.
What unique academic or extracurricular programs are available at private schools accessible to families in Atlanta, New York?
Families in Atlanta, NY, benefit from private schools that leverage the resources of the Rochester area. Unique programs include robust STEM partnerships with local universities and companies like Kodak and Xerox, prominent at McQuaid Jesuit. The Harley School features a renowned environmental sustainability program with on-campus gardens and wetlands. Allendale Columbia offers exceptional global studies, including extensive language programs and study abroad opportunities. For arts, many schools have partnerships with the Eastman School of Music and the Memorial Art Gallery. These connections provide Atlanta students with opportunities rarely found in typical public school settings.
What is the typical enrollment timeline and process for private schools serving the Atlanta, NY, community?
The enrollment process for private schools in the Rochester/Atlanta area is structured and begins early. The main intake is for the fall semester, with key steps occurring a full year in advance. The timeline usually involves: attending open houses from September to November, submitting applications by January/February, completing student visits and assessments in winter, and receiving admission decisions in March. Financial aid applications (like SSS) are due concurrently. For families in Atlanta, NY, it's important to plan for potential transportation, as some schools may be a 30-45 minute commute. Starting the process in the fall of the year before desired entry is strongly advised.
For a family in Atlanta, NY, what are the primary considerations when choosing between the local public school (in the Honeoye Central School District) and a private school in the Rochester area?
The decision hinges on several location-specific factors. The Honeoye Central School District offers a small, community-focused K-12 environment with a lower student-to-teacher ratio than many suburban districts. Choosing a private school in Rochester involves weighing a longer daily commute against access to specialized programs, different religious or philosophical foundations (like Jesuit education at McQuaid), and often more extensive college counseling networks. Private schools may offer more language options, advanced arts curricula, and specific learning support. The cost, of course, is paramount, but many families find the investment worthwhile for the specific educational environment or specialized program not available in their local public school.
Private Education Insights
Find the Best Private High Schools in Atlanta and New York: A Parent's Guide
When you begin searching for "private high schools near me" in Atlanta, New York, you're tapping into a rich educational landscape that blends small-town community values with access to the cultural and academic resources of the greater Rochester region. Atlanta itself, a charming hamlet in the town of Cohocton, offers a serene, family-oriented environment, yet parents here are uniquely positioned to consider several exceptional private high schools within a reasonable commute. This search is less about proximity and more about finding the right educational fit—a place that aligns with your child’s aspirations and your family’s values, all within the context of our Upstate New York lifestyle.
Your local options include schools that have built strong reputations over decades, serving families from Atlanta and surrounding communities like Avon, Dansville, and Wayland. Allendale Columbia School, located in nearby Pittsford, is often at the top of many parents' lists. Known for its progressive, student-centered approach, Allendale Columbia emphasizes experiential learning and global citizenship. For a family in Atlanta, this could mean your child engages in deep, project-based learning during the day and returns home to the quiet, star-filled nights of rural living—a balance that many find ideal. The Harley School, also in Rochester, offers another compelling choice with its focus on Montessori-inspired education in the early years transitioning to a rigorous college-prep curriculum. Its commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion resonates with families seeking a socially conscious environment.
For those considering a faith-based education, McQuaid Jesuit in Brighton provides a strong all-boys option with a renowned academic program rooted in Jesuit principles of intellectual excellence and service to others. The commute from Atlanta to McQuaid is a familiar one for many local families, often forming carpools that turn into lasting friendships. It’s important to consider these drives not as a hurdle, but as part of the daily rhythm. The 30 to 45-minute journey can become valuable transition time and connects your child to a broader network of opportunities, including advanced STEM labs, arts programs, and competitive athletics that smaller local public schools may not offer.
As you research, remember that the private school admission process in our area is nuanced. Visiting these campuses is crucial; you’ll want to feel the culture for yourself. Talk to admission officers about transportation options—many schools have bus routes or van services that extend into rural areas like ours. Inquire about financial aid, as these institutions are committed to socioeconomic diversity. Ultimately, your search for "private high schools near me" in Atlanta, NY, is a journey toward finding a community that will challenge and nurture your teenager, preparing them not just for college, but for a life of purpose, all while allowing them to maintain their roots in the beautiful Finger Lakes foothills we call home.