Private Schools in Bay Shore, New York

St. Patrick School is a highly-regarded Catholic elementary school serving Bay Shore families for over six decades. The school offers a comprehensive Pre-K through 8th grade education with strong emphasis on faith-based values and academic excellence. Their curriculum includes advanced STEM programs, integrated arts education, and technology integration across all grade levels. The school maintains small class sizes with dedicated certified teachers and features modern facilities including science labs, computer labs, and extensive athletic programs. Parent satisfaction is exceptionally high with families appreciating the strong community atmosphere and rigorous academic preparation for high school.

Our Lady of Mercy Academy is a highly-regarded all-girls Catholic high school serving students from Bay Shore and throughout Long Island. The school offers an exceptional college preparatory program with 100% of graduates accepted to four-year colleges. Their curriculum includes extensive Advanced Placement offerings, a specialized STEM Academy, and comprehensive arts programs. The 30-acre campus features modern science and technology labs, performing arts centers, and athletic facilities. OLMA emphasizes leadership development, community service, and academic excellence within a supportive all-girls environment. The school provides transportation services for Bay Shore area students and maintains a strong reputation for preparing young women for college success and leadership roles.

Located just minutes from Bay Shore in St. James, The Knox School is a prestigious independent college preparatory school serving day and boarding students from Pre-K through 12th grade. With over a century of educational excellence, the school offers a rigorous academic program featuring Advanced Placement courses, comprehensive STEM education, and outstanding visual and performing arts programs. The campus features state-of-the-art facilities including science laboratories, athletic complexes, and dedicated arts spaces. Knox emphasizes personalized learning with an 8:1 student-teacher ratio and provides extensive college counseling with graduates consistently accepted to top-tier universities. The school serves many Bay Shore families seeking a challenging academic environment.