The Best Private Schools in Fishers, New York
Discover 3 exceptional private schools in Fishers. Find the perfect educational environment for your child with our comprehensive reviews and ratings.
School Overview
Top-Rated Private Schools
The Harley School
Independent School
The Harley School is a highly-regarded independent school serving the Greater Rochester area, including Fishers. Founded in 1917, it offers a comprehensive education from Montessori early childhood through high school. The school is known for its International Baccalaureate Diploma Program, strong STEM curriculum, and exceptional arts programs. With small class sizes and a student-centered approach, Harley emphasizes critical thinking, creativity, and character development. The campus features modern facilities including science labs, art studios, and athletic spaces, serving students from Fishers and surrounding communities.
Programs:
Allendale Columbia School
Independent School
Allendale Columbia School is a prestigious independent day school serving students from Fishers and the Greater Rochester region. With roots dating back to 1890, the school offers a rigorous academic program from pre-kindergarten through grade 12. Known for its strong college preparatory curriculum, Allendale Columbia features extensive Advanced Placement offerings, global education programs, and innovative entrepreneurship initiatives. The school maintains a 7:1 student-to-teacher ratio and offers comprehensive athletic and arts programs. Their campus includes state-of-the-art facilities and serves as a top educational choice for families in the Fishers area.
Programs:
McQuaid Jesuit
Jesuit Schools Network
McQuaid Jesuit is a premier Catholic college preparatory school for young men, serving students from Fishers and throughout the Rochester metropolitan area. Founded in 1954, the school combines rigorous academics with character formation in the Jesuit tradition. The curriculum includes extensive Advanced Placement courses, a dedicated STEM Academy, and comprehensive arts programs. McQuaid features modern facilities including science and technology labs, athletic complexes, and performing arts spaces. With strong college placement records and a focus on forming "men for others," McQuaid provides transportation services that make it accessible to Fishers residents.
Programs:
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about private schools in Fishers, New York
What are the primary private school options serving families in Fishers, New York, and what are their key characteristics?
Fishers, NY, is part of the greater Rochester area and is primarily served by several prestigious private schools located in nearby suburbs. The top options include The Harley School in Brighton (progressive, Pre-K-12, with a strong focus on experiential learning), Allendale Columbia School in Pittsford (Pre-K-12, known for its global perspective and innovative curriculum), and McQuaid Jesuit in Brighton (all-boys, grades 5-12, offering a rigorous college-prep education rooted in Jesuit values). While Fishers itself is a smaller hamlet, these schools are a standard commute for local families and represent the core of private education available to residents. It's important to visit each to understand their distinct cultures and educational philosophies.
How does tuition for private schools in the Fishers, NY, area compare, and what financial aid options are typically available?
Tuition for the leading private schools near Fishers, NY, is significant and aligns with the high cost of similar institutions in New York State. For the 2024-2025 academic year, expect tuition ranges of approximately $25,000 to $35,000+ for upper grades. All the mentioned schools—Harley, Allendale Columbia, and McQuaid Jesuit—have robust financial aid programs based on demonstrated need. They use systems like the School and Student Services (SSS) by NAIS to assess eligibility. New York State also offers some support, such as the Child Safety Fund tax credit for certain safety-related expenses. It's crucial to apply for financial aid early, as deadlines often precede admission decisions.
What unique academic or extracurricular programs do private schools in the Fishers/Rochester area offer that leverage local resources?
Private schools in the Fishers/Rochester region excel in programs that connect students to the area's rich cultural, scientific, and business communities. The Harley School emphasizes environmental science and sustainability, with partnerships at local nature preserves. Allendale Columbia leverages Rochester's history of innovation with strong entrepreneurship and engineering programs, often collaborating with local universities like RIT and UR. McQuaid Jesuit offers extensive community service requirements that engage with Rochester's urban core, alongside strong robotics and science competitions. Many also have unique outdoor education trips that utilize the Finger Lakes and Adirondack regions.
What is the typical enrollment timeline and process for private schools near Fishers, NY, and when should we start?
The admission process for competitive private schools in the Fishers area is extensive and should begin at least a year in advance. The standard timeline starts in the fall (September-October) with open houses and tours for the following academic year. Application deadlines are typically in January or February, with required components including student visits/interviews, teacher recommendations, standardized testing (like the ISEE or SSAT), and school records. Admission decisions are communicated in March. For schools like McQuaid Jesuit with a 5th-grade entry point, planning should start even earlier, often in 3rd or 4th grade. We recommend initiating research and campus visits in the fall of the year before you wish to enroll.
For a family in Fishers, what are the key considerations when choosing between the local public school (Victor Central School District) and a private school?
This is a pivotal decision for Fishers families. The Victor Central School District is highly rated, offering a strong academic program with no tuition. Choosing a private school involves evaluating the return on a significant investment. Key considerations include: **Educational Approach** (progressive at Harley vs. traditional college-prep at McQuaid vs. the public district's standard model), **Class Size** (private schools often have 15-18 students vs. larger public classes), **Specialization** (private schools may offer more tailored programs in arts, languages, or faith-based education), and **Community** (a smaller, self-selected community vs. the broader district). The commute to a private school (20-30 minutes) versus the local bus to a Victor school is also a practical factor. Ultimately, it depends on which environment best aligns with your child's needs and your family's values.