Private Schools in Lancaster, New York

St. Mary's Elementary School is a highly-regarded Catholic school serving the Lancaster community for over six decades. The school offers a comprehensive Pre-K through 8th grade education with a strong emphasis on faith formation, academic excellence, and character development. Their curriculum includes advanced STEM programs, comprehensive arts education, and competitive sports teams. The school features modern classrooms, a dedicated science lab, music room, and gymnasium. Parent satisfaction is exceptionally high with praise for the dedicated teachers, strong community atmosphere, and well-rounded educational approach that prepares students for high school success.

The Buffalo Seminary is one of Western New York's premier independent college preparatory schools for girls, serving students from Lancaster and throughout the region. This historic institution offers a rigorous academic program with extensive Advanced Placement course offerings, outstanding arts programs, and competitive athletics. The school features state-of-the-art science laboratories, performing arts spaces, and athletic facilities. With small class sizes and personalized attention, Seminary provides an empowering environment where young women excel academically and develop leadership skills. The school has an exceptional college placement record and strong alumni network.

Nichols School is a highly selective co-educational independent school serving students from Lancaster and the greater Buffalo area. The school offers a comprehensive college preparatory curriculum including International Baccalaureate and Advanced Placement programs across all disciplines. Nichols features exceptional facilities including modern science centers, extensive athletic complexes, performing arts theaters, and technology-rich learning spaces. The school emphasizes balanced excellence in academics, arts, and athletics with a diverse student body and dedicated faculty. Parent and alumni satisfaction is very high, with graduates consistently attending top-tier colleges and universities nationwide.