BestPrivateSchoolsNear.me
Excellence Verified

The Best Private Schools in Lima, New York

Discover 3 exceptional private schools in Lima. Find the perfect educational environment for your child with our comprehensive reviews and ratings.

3
Private Schools
4.4
Average Rating
0
Total Students
2
School Types

School Overview

0
Religious Schools
3
Secular Schools
2
Different Types

Top-Rated Private Schools

McQuaid Jesuit

Jesuit Schools Network

4.5

McQuaid Jesuit is a Catholic college preparatory school for young men serving the Rochester region, including Lima families. Founded in the Jesuit educational tradition, the school offers a rigorous academic program with particular strengths in STEM, humanities, and service learning. The 35-acre campus features advanced science and technology labs, extensive athletic facilities, and dedicated arts spaces. With a college acceptance rate of 100%, McQuaid emphasizes character formation alongside academic excellence. The school maintains small class sizes and offers extensive extracurricular opportunities including robotics, debate, and championship athletic programs.

1800 South Clinton Avenue, Rochester, NY 14618, Lima, New York NY 14618
Grades: K-12
Founded 1954

Programs:

Jesuit College PreparatorySTEM AcademyHumanities Program

The Harley School

Independent

4.4

The Harley School is a highly-regarded independent school serving the Greater Rochester area, including Lima. Founded in 1917, it offers a comprehensive education from early childhood through 12th grade. The school features an International Baccalaureate Diploma Programme for upper grades and maintains small class sizes with a student-teacher ratio of 7:1. The 25-acre campus includes modern science labs, art studios, athletic facilities, and dedicated spaces for performing arts. Harley emphasizes experiential learning, community engagement, and academic excellence with 100% of graduates attending four-year colleges.

1981 Clover Street, Rochester, NY 14618, Lima, New York NY 14618
Grades: K-12
Founded 1917

Programs:

Montessori Early ChildhoodInternational Baccalaureate Diploma ProgrammeCollege Preparatory Curriculum

Allendale Columbia School

Independent

4.3

Allendale Columbia School is a prestigious independent school serving students from preschool through grade 12, drawing families from Lima and surrounding communities. The school offers the International Baccalaureate Programme alongside advanced placement options, with a strong emphasis on global education and language acquisition. Facilities include state-of-the-art science laboratories, innovation spaces, athletic complexes, and performing arts centers. With a student-teacher ratio of 8:1, the school provides personalized attention and has a strong college placement record, with graduates attending top-tier universities nationwide.

519 Allens Creek Road, Rochester, NY 14618, Lima, New York NY 14618
Grades: K-12
Founded 1890

Programs:

International Baccalaureate ProgrammeWorld LanguagesSTEM Focus

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about private schools in Lima, New York

What are the primary private school options available for families residing in Lima, New York, and are there transportation services?

While Lima itself is a small hamlet, families have access to several highly-regarded private schools in the greater Rochester area, a short commute away. The most prominent include The Harley School in Rochester (progressive, independent), Allendale Columbia School in Pittsford (independent, college prep), and McQuaid Jesuit in Brighton (all-boys, Catholic). It is important to note that these schools are not located within Lima's borders. Most families drive or carpool, and some schools may offer limited busing or transportation services for a fee through arrangements with local districts or private carriers. Investigating each school's specific transportation policy is a crucial step for Lima residents.

How does tuition for top private schools near Lima, NY, compare, and what financial aid options are available through New York State programs?

Tuition for the leading private schools in the Rochester region varies. For the 2024-2025 academic year, expect ranges from approximately $20,000 to over $30,000 for upper schools, with lower rates for younger grades. Beyond need-based financial aid offered directly by each school, New York State residents should explore two key programs. The first is the Tuition Assistance Program (TAP) for post-secondary education, which is not applicable for K-12. More relevant are potential education tax credits. Critically, New York does not have a school voucher or tax-credit scholarship program for K-12 private education, so primary funding comes from school-based aid, scholarships, and personal resources.

What unique academic or extracurricular programs do private schools near Lima, NY, offer that leverage the local environment or institutions?

Schools in the Rochester area capitalize on local resources to create distinctive programs. The Harley School and Allendale Columbia often have partnerships with nearby universities like the University of Rochester and RIT, providing advanced research opportunities, college courses, and mentorship for high school students. McQuaid Jesuit emphasizes its engineering and robotics programs, which can connect with local industry. Furthermore, the region's focus on technology, optics, and agriculture influences STEM curricula and project-based learning. Many schools also utilize the cultural assets of Rochester, including the Memorial Art Gallery, the Strong Museum, and the Rochester Philharmonic Orchestra, for integrated learning experiences.

What is the typical enrollment timeline and process for competitive private schools in the Lima, NY, area, and when should we start?

The admission process for schools like Harley, Allendale Columbia, and McQuaid Jesuit is structured and often begins over a year in advance. The standard timeline starts with open houses in the fall (September-October) for entry the following academic year. Application deadlines are typically in January or February, with assessments, student visits, and interviews occurring in the winter. Admission decisions are communicated in March. For families in Lima, it is highly advisable to begin research and attend open houses in the fall of the year *before* you wish your child to enroll (e.g., fall 2024 for fall 2025 entry). Waiting lists are common, so early engagement is key.

For a family living in Lima's rural setting, what are the key considerations when choosing between the local public school (Honeoye Falls-Lima Central School District) and a private school in Rochester?

This decision hinges on several location-specific factors. The Honeoye Falls-Lima (HFL) district offers a well-regarded public education with the convenience of proximity, community integration, and no tuition. Choosing a private school in Rochester involves a significant daily commute (20-30+ minutes each way), tuition cost, and potentially less daily interaction with neighborhood peers. However, it may offer smaller class sizes, specialized religious or pedagogical approaches (like Montessori or Jesuit), and different extracurricular emphases. Lima parents must weigh the value of the specific private school program against the logistical and financial investment of commuting to the metro area, as well as the quality of the local HFL option.

Private Education Insights

Choosing the Best Private Kindergarten in Lima, NY: A Parent's Guide

For families in Lima, New York, the decision about where to begin your child’s formal education is a significant one. The choice of a private kindergarten can set a powerful trajectory, offering a tailored, foundational year that blends academic readiness with social-emotional growth. In our community, nestled within the broader Rochester region, parents have access to several exceptional private institutions, each providing a distinct approach to these formative early years. Understanding the local landscape is key to finding the right fit for your family’s values and your child’s unique needs.

The hallmark of private kindergarten in Lima is often its low student-to-teacher ratio. This isn't just about smaller class sizes; it's about intentional, personalized attention. In a classroom of twelve to fifteen students, educators at schools like The Harley School or Allendale Columbia can truly know each child—their learning style, their curiosities, and the moments they need gentle encouragement. This environment allows kindergarten to move beyond a standard curriculum into a realm of guided discovery. You’ll find programs emphasizing hands-on, experiential learning, whether it’s through scientific exploration in a dedicated lab, creative expression in an art studio, or early literacy woven into project-based themes relevant to our Finger Lakes surroundings.

When considering options, it’s valuable to look at the philosophical continuity from kindergarten onward. A school like McQuaid Jesuit, while an all-boys institution starting in junior kindergarten, builds a foundation rooted in character, service, and community from the very beginning. This long-term perspective is a significant benefit of private education; you are choosing not just a kindergarten, but a cohesive educational pathway. Many Lima families appreciate the seamless transition from these early years into robust lower school programs, avoiding the uncertainty of future school changes. The daily logistics also warrant local consideration. While Lima itself offers a serene, suburban setting, commuting to campuses in nearby Pittsford or Brighton is a common part of life for many families here. The drive is often seen as a worthwhile investment for the specialized environment, but it’s a practical factor to weigh alongside carpool possibilities and after-school care programs, which these schools typically structure with working parents in mind.

The investment in private kindergarten is as much about community as it is about academics. You are joining a partnership with educators who are specialists in early childhood development and connecting with other families who share a proactive commitment to their children’s education. We encourage Lima parents to move beyond brochures and websites. Schedule visits, observe classrooms in action, and ask kindergarten teachers about a typical day. Notice how children interact and how teachers facilitate play and problem-solving. The right environment will feel like a natural extension of the nurturing you provide at home, yet will challenge your child to grow in confidence and capability. This careful choice in kindergarten can lay a joyful and resilient foundation for all the learning that follows.

Nearby Cities

Explore private schools in nearby cities