Private Schools in Youngstown, New York

St. Paul's School is a highly-regarded Catholic elementary school serving the Youngstown and surrounding Niagara County communities. Located just minutes from Youngstown in nearby Olcott, this established institution provides a faith-based education with strong academic foundations. The school offers small class sizes, individualized attention, and a comprehensive curriculum that includes core academic subjects, religious education, music, and arts programs. Parents consistently praise the dedicated faculty, safe learning environment, and strong sense of community. The school maintains excellent facilities and offers various extracurricular activities that complement its rigorous academic program.

Stella Niagara Education Park is a prestigious Catholic private school located just south of Youngstown along the Niagara River. This historic institution offers comprehensive education from pre-kindergarten through 12th grade, serving students from Youngstown and throughout Western New York. The school features an International Baccalaureate program, strong college preparatory curriculum, and advanced STEM offerings. With exceptional facilities including modern classrooms, science labs, athletic facilities, and performing arts spaces, Stella Niagara provides a well-rounded education. The school is particularly noted for its academic excellence, dedicated faculty, and strong college acceptance rates, making it a top choice for families in the Youngstown area.

Nichols School is one of Western New York's premier independent college preparatory schools, serving students from Youngstown and throughout the greater Buffalo-Niagara region. Located approximately 30 minutes from Youngstown in Buffalo, this highly respected institution offers a rigorous academic program with extensive Advanced Placement course options, competitive athletics, and comprehensive arts programs. The school features state-of-the-art facilities, small class sizes, and exceptional faculty with advanced degrees. Nichols consistently achieves outstanding college placement results and is known for developing well-rounded students through its balanced emphasis on academics, character development, and extracurricular engagement. The school provides transportation options for students from Niagara County communities.