Private Schools in Kelleys Island, Ohio

St. John Lutheran School is a highly-regarded Christian private school serving the Lake Erie islands community, including Kelleys Island families. Located in nearby Port Clinton, the school provides comprehensive education from preschool through 8th grade with small class sizes and individualized attention. The curriculum integrates faith-based learning with strong academic foundations, featuring dedicated STEM programs, music education, and competitive sports. Facilities include modern classrooms, science labs, and athletic fields. The school is known for its tight-knit community atmosphere and high parent satisfaction, making it a popular choice for island families seeking quality private education with transportation options available.

St. Mary Central Catholic School serves as the primary Catholic high school for the Lake Erie islands region, drawing students from Kelleys Island and surrounding communities. The school offers a rigorous college preparatory curriculum with Advanced Placement courses, comprehensive STEM programs, and competitive athletics. Located in Sandusky, approximately 30 minutes from the ferry terminal, the school provides bus transportation options for island students. Facilities include modern science laboratories, technology-enhanced classrooms, and extensive athletic facilities. With a strong track record of college acceptance and high parent satisfaction ratings, St. Mary's combines academic excellence with character formation in the Catholic tradition.

St. Peter School in Huron provides quality Catholic education serving families throughout the Lake Erie islands, including Kelleys Island. This established elementary school offers education from preschool through 8th grade with a focus on academic excellence and spiritual development. The curriculum features strong foundational academics enhanced by technology integration, Spanish language instruction, and comprehensive fine arts programs. The school maintains small class sizes and personalized learning approaches. Located conveniently near the Huron ferry access point, the school serves as a practical option for island families seeking private education with before/after school care options and a supportive community environment known for high parent satisfaction.