The Best Private Schools in Shelby, Ohio
Discover 3 exceptional private schools in Shelby. Find the perfect educational environment for your child with our comprehensive reviews and ratings.
School Overview
Top-Rated Private Schools
St. Peter's Elementary & Middle School
Roman Catholic Diocese of Toledo
St. Peter's is a highly-regarded Catholic school serving the Shelby area and greater Richland County. With a 60+ year history, the school offers a comprehensive education from preschool through 8th grade with strong emphasis on faith formation, academic excellence, and character development. The school features modern facilities, dedicated teachers with an average of 15+ years experience, and a robust curriculum that includes advanced STEM programs, fine arts, and competitive athletics. Parents consistently praise the tight-knit community atmosphere and individualized attention students receive.
Programs:
Lexington Christian Academy
Independent Christian School
Lexington Christian Academy serves students from Shelby and surrounding communities with a comprehensive college-preparatory program grounded in Christian values. The school offers small class sizes with a student-teacher ratio of 12:1, advanced placement courses, and extensive extracurricular opportunities including competitive sports, music programs, and community service initiatives. The campus features modern technology labs, athletic facilities, and dedicated arts spaces. The school is known for its strong academic outcomes with 98% of graduates attending four-year colleges.
Programs:
Mansfield Christian School
Independent Christian School
Mansfield Christian School provides a complete K-12 education serving families throughout Richland County, including Shelby. With over five decades of operation, the school has established a strong reputation for academic rigor combined with Christian character development. The comprehensive program includes advanced STEM courses, extensive fine arts offerings, competitive athletic teams, and college counseling services. The 40-acre campus features state-of-the-art facilities including science labs, performing arts center, and athletic complex. The school maintains accreditation and consistently produces graduates who excel in higher education.
Programs:
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about private schools in Shelby, Ohio
What are the primary private school options available for families living in or near Shelby, Ohio?
Families in Shelby, Ohio, have several well-regarded private school options, though many are located in nearby communities. Within Shelby itself, St. Peter's Elementary & Middle School (PreK-8) offers a Catholic education. For high school and broader K-12 options, parents often look to schools in neighboring towns such as Lexington Christian Academy (K-12) in Lexington and Mansfield Christian School (PreK-12) in Mansfield. These schools typically serve students from Shelby and surrounding Richland County, with transportation sometimes provided via parent carpool networks or limited bus service. Exploring these nearby options is essential as Shelby's on-site private choices are limited.
How does tuition at private schools in the Shelby, Ohio, area compare, and are there financial aid options specific to Ohio?
Tuition in the Shelby area varies by school and grade level. For the 2024-2025 academic year, St. Peter's Elementary & Middle School typically has a parish-subsidized tuition ranging from $3,000 to $5,000 annually. Lexington Christian Academy and Mansfield Christian School, as independent Christian schools, often have tuition ranging from $6,000 to $9,000 per year for elementary grades, with high school being higher. A significant financial consideration for Ohio families is the state's EdChoice Scholarship Program. This program provides vouchers based on either household income or the performance rating of your assigned public school district (Shelby City Schools), which can substantially reduce out-of-pocket costs. All mentioned schools have financial aid processes and accept EdChoice scholarships.
What unique academic or extracurricular programs do private schools near Shelby, Ohio, offer that differentiate them?
Private schools near Shelby often emphasize specific missions that shape their programs. St. Peter's integrates Catholic faith and sacramental preparation throughout its curriculum. Lexington Christian Academy is known for its strong college-prep academics and a wide array of athletics and arts, often competing in the Mid-Buckeye Conference. Mansfield Christian School offers distinctive programs like a dedicated STEM lab, agricultural science opportunities reflecting the region's character, and robust music and drama productions. A common thread is smaller class sizes, allowing for more individualized attention than might be found in larger public districts. These schools often leverage their size to create a close-knit, community-focused environment.
What is the typical enrollment timeline and process for private schools serving Shelby, Ohio, families?
The enrollment process for schools like St. Peter's, Lexington Christian, and Mansfield Christian generally begins in January or February for the following fall. It's crucial to apply early, especially for limited seats in kindergarten or popular grades. The process typically involves submitting an application, academic records, teacher recommendations, and often a family interview or student assessment. Many schools host open houses in the fall and winter. A key consideration for Shelby families is transportation; while Shelby City Schools may not provide busing to private schools outside the district, some private schools organize private bus routes or have established carpool communities. Confirming logistics is a vital step after acceptance.
For a family in Shelby, what are the practical considerations when choosing between Shelby City Schools and a private school in the area?
The decision involves several local factors. Shelby City Schools offer the convenience of neighborhood busing, no tuition, and strong athletic programs, notably in track and field. The private school alternative, while involving tuition and more complex transportation logistics, typically offers smaller class sizes, a specific religious or value-based education (if desired), and potentially different academic pacing. For Ohio families, the EdChoice Scholarship can make private school financially accessible. Culturally, some Shelby families value the deep community roots and continuity of the public system, while others seek the specialized environment and mission of a private school. Visiting both types—attending a Shelby Whippets event and a private school open house—can provide the clearest comparison for your child's needs.