The Best Private Schools in Plymouth, Wisconsin
Discover 3 exceptional private schools in Plymouth. Find the perfect educational environment for your child with our comprehensive reviews and ratings.
School Overview
Top-Rated Private Schools
St. John Lutheran School
St. John Lutheran Church
St. John Lutheran School is a highly-regarded Christian private school serving students from preschool through 8th grade. The school emphasizes faith-based education combined with strong academic fundamentals, featuring small class sizes and individualized attention. Their comprehensive curriculum includes advanced mathematics, science labs, language arts, and technology integration. The school offers extensive extracurricular opportunities including choir, band, sports teams, and community service programs. Parents consistently praise the nurturing environment, dedicated teachers, and strong sense of community. The campus includes modern classrooms, a gymnasium, science lab, and outdoor recreational facilities.
Programs:
Sheboygan Area Lutheran High School
Lutheran High School Association
Located just 15 minutes from Plymouth, Sheboygan Area Lutheran High School serves as the premier Christian high school option for Plymouth families. The school offers a rigorous college-preparatory curriculum with Advanced Placement courses, dual enrollment opportunities, and specialized programs in STEM, business, and fine arts. Students benefit from a 12:1 student-teacher ratio and comprehensive college counseling. The campus features state-of-the-art science labs, performing arts center, athletic complex, and technology-integrated classrooms. Extracurricular offerings include championship athletic teams, competitive robotics, drama productions, and mission trips. The school maintains strong academic results with graduates consistently attending top universities.
Programs:
Sheboygan Christian School
Christian Schools International
Serving students from Plymouth and surrounding communities, Sheboygan Christian School provides comprehensive Christian education from preschool through 8th grade. The school integrates biblical principles throughout its academic program while maintaining high standards in core subjects. Their curriculum emphasizes critical thinking, project-based learning, and technology integration with 1:1 device programs in upper grades. The school features specialized classrooms for science, art, music, and technology, along with modern playground facilities and gymnasium. Parent satisfaction is exceptionally high, with families praising the strong community values, academic excellence, and character development focus. The school offers before/after school care and extensive extracurricular activities including sports, choir, and academic competitions.
Programs:
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about private schools in Plymouth, Wisconsin
What are the primary private school options available for families living in Plymouth, Wisconsin?
While Plymouth itself is home to St. John Lutheran School (PK-8), many families in the area also consider schools in nearby Sheboygan for a full K-12 continuum. Notable options include Sheboygan Area Lutheran High School (grades 9-12) and Sheboygan Christian School (PK-8). These schools are common choices for Plymouth residents due to their Lutheran and Christian foundations, proximity (a 15-20 minute commute), and established community ties. There are no independent, non-sectarian private schools within Plymouth's immediate city limits, making these faith-based institutions the primary private alternatives to the Plymouth Joint School District.
How does tuition at Plymouth-area private schools compare to the Wisconsin state average, and what financial aid options exist?
Tuition for the primary private schools serving Plymouth tends to be below the state average for private schools, reflecting the region's cost of living. For the 2024-2025 school year, St. John Lutheran School in Plymouth has tuition around $4,500-$5,500 for elementary grades, with multi-child discounts. Sheboygan Area Lutheran High School tuition is approximately $9,000. Wisconsin offers the Parental Choice Program, a voucher system that can significantly reduce costs for eligible families. Importantly, all the schools mentioned (St. John Lutheran, Sheboygan Area Lutheran, and Sheboygan Christian) participate in this program, making them potentially much more affordable for qualifying Plymouth residents based on income.
What unique academic or extracurricular programs do private schools in the Plymouth area offer that leverage local community resources?
Private schools in the Plymouth area often integrate the region's strong agricultural, manufacturing, and cultural heritage into their programs. For example, science and environmental studies may include field trips to local dairy farms or the Kettle Moraine State Forest. Given Plymouth's identity as "The Cheese Capital of the World," some schools incorporate local history and business tours into their curriculum. Sheboygan Area Lutheran High School offers robust music and theater programs that sometimes collaborate with local arts organizations. Furthermore, these schools typically emphasize community service, partnering with local Plymouth events like Cheese Capital Days or food pantries, fostering a strong sense of local civic engagement.
What is the typical enrollment timeline and process for private schools like St. John Lutheran in Plymouth, and are there waitlists?
The enrollment process for Plymouth's private schools often begins in January or February for the following fall, with priority given to re-enrolling students and siblings. St. John Lutheran School typically hosts open houses in the winter. Due to their smaller sizes compared to public districts, popular grades can fill quickly, but widespread waitlists are less common than in larger metropolitan areas. A key step is the application and family interview, which is standard for these faith-based schools. For Sheboygan Area Lutheran High School, which draws from Plymouth, 8th-grade students usually apply during their fall semester. It's highly recommended for Plymouth parents to make direct contact with the school's admissions office by December to ensure a spot and complete any necessary financial aid or Wisconsin Choice Program paperwork.
For a Plymouth family, what are the key considerations when choosing between the local public schools and the available private school options?
The decision often centers on educational philosophy, class size, and religious instruction. Plymouth's public schools (Plymouth Joint School District) are well-regarded and offer a comprehensive, secular education with diverse extracurriculars. The private options, all Christian Lutheran, provide integrated religious education, typically smaller class sizes (often 15-20 students), and a consistent values-based environment from preschool through high school. A practical consideration is logistics: St. John Lutheran offers a PK-8 option within Plymouth, but for a private Lutheran high school, commuting to Sheboygan is necessary. Financially, the Wisconsin Parental Choice Program can level the cost difference for eligible families. Ultimately, the choice for Plymouth residents hinges on whether they prioritize the specific faith-based community and intimate setting of the private schools or the broader programs and proximity of the public system, especially at the high school level.
Nearby Cities
Explore private schools in nearby cities